When the auto-enrolment process finally got under way in October 2012, no one knew exactly what to expect. For some employers, it was little more than tinkering with an existing system; for others, it was a major project involving entering most of their workforce into a workplace pension scheme for the first time.
If you read nothing else, read this…
- Most staff are remaining in pension plans once they have been auto-enrolled.
- Many employers are using the opportunity to promote their wider benefits package.
- There is some evidence of employers accompanying auto-enrolment with financial awareness sessions.
- Employers are not cutting other perks to cover auto-enrolment costs, but some insurance policies are being scaled back.
- Some employers are linking benefit and pension schemes to ease administration.
Eight months on, things have become a little clearer. The most striking aspect has been the relatively low level of opt-outs. In the run-up to auto-enrolment, surveys predicted opt-out rates in excess of 30%, but the reality has been different. Will Aitken, senior consultant at Towers Watson, says: “The normal take-up we’ve seen has been 90-95% and that’s pretty much across the board, even in populations that are supposedly very unengaged.”
Pension contribution levels
Employers have also resisted the temptation to level down contributions. Instead, where they had a large non-pensioned population, the tendency has been to create a separate plan, offering the minimum levels of contribution required under auto-enrolment, running alongside an existing scheme.
Charles Cotton, performance and reward adviser at the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD), says: “There is often a mechanism for people to graduate from that type of arrangement to one that had been offered to existing employees when they have been around for a certain length of time, or have shown a certain amount of commitment to the organisation.”
Over time, this could lead to a levelling down by stealth, Aitken says. “It’s not explicit because people who are already in the scheme are not getting lower contributions, but as time goes on, those new people will become the norm,” he says. “It might only emerge over a decade or so, but it is happening.”
Some employers are using auto-enrolment as part of a broader reward strategy to promote the wider use of benefits and introduce new ones that will help them achieve better staff engagement and retention. “It’s only the larger organisations that have wrestled with this, but there seems to be more of a holistic approach to wealth management, as well as issues around financial literacy and awareness,” says Cotton.
Research conducted by Employee Benefits confirms this. According to The Benefits Research 2013, published in May, 62% of employers said their benefits strategy for 2013 would be influenced directly by auto-enrolment, and 21% by concerns around an ageing workforce.
Philip Smith, principal and head of defined contribution and wealth at Buck Consultants, says: “[Employers] are trying to give employees a wake-up call and show them they won’t be able to walk out of the door at age 55 like the previous generation did. They are beginning to invest in member engagement strategies, putting in place online tools, running seminars and getting people to come into the workplace to offer not necessarily advice but information.”
Financial planning education
Helen Bidgway, head of HR at The Whitgift Foundation, a charity that operates care homes and schools, says the organisation is offering above-minimum contribution levels for staff who are not currently in its existing pension scheme, automatically enrolling them with an employer contribution of 4% and staff putting in 2%. It is also offering financial seminars, provided by Secondsight, to boost take-up.
“We are offering people the opportunity to have a one-to-one session before they join the scheme to make them think about what pensions they already have, and how much they might want on retirement,” she says.
Emma Douglas, head of workplace savings at Mercer, says the launch of auto-enrolment should, in theory, be a good time for employers to think about additional financial products, such as corporate individual savings accounts (Isas).
“It’s a great time to have a conversation about the wider benefits structure, but that has tended not to be the case because people are focused on getting the auto-enrolment bit right,” she says.
The Benefits Research confirms this: the number of employers looking to provide financial advice stood at 17% in 2013, the same as in 2009.
However, some employers are using auto-enrolment as an opportunity to promote their existing benefits offering. Clare Abrahams, head of auto-enrolment at Lorica Employee Benefits, cites fast-food retailer KFC as an example.
“For KFC, it was all about employee engagement, including developing substantial communications and pitching the benefits in a way that would be appreciated by employees,” she says. “It had one-to-one sessions, presentations and workshops, online learning tools, posters in the workplace, training for managers to help communicate the changes to their team members and full benefit branding with sweets, magnets and Post-It notes.
“It is the perfect example of going above and beyond what its statutory duties would require to really help employees understand and embrace their benefits.”
Cost-reduction exercises
However, there are signs that other businesses may look to reduce benefits, perhaps in order to meet higher-than-expected costs from auto-enrolment. Towers Watson’s Aitken identifies a trend towards fixed-period benefits for group income protection rather than paying out until age 65, as well as higher excesses being introduced around private medical insurance. “It effectively throws some of the cost on to employees,” he says. “This is happening in parallel, but it’s hard to say whether it’s a result of auto-enrolment.”
Buck Consultants’ Smith, meanwhile, suggests there is a move to restrict certain benefits that have traditionally been offered alongside pensions, such as life cover, to those already in existing plans.
“We haven’t seen the extension of benefits packages to those populations in the way you might expect,” he says.
Smith cites the example of one [employer] that was perfectly happy to offer the ‘full-fat’ pension scheme with four-times-salary life cover for people who enrolled voluntarily, but offered just one-times salary to those who were auto-enrolled.
Other employers are using the introduction of auto-enrolment to overhaul how their benefit schemes are set up. James Gilbert, pensions consultant at Thomsons Online Benefits, says some employers have taken the opportunity to consolidate existing benefits in their flexible and total reward packages.
Administrative burden
“Where auto-enrolment has required the implementation of technology to minimise the administrative burden, it has made sense to put other existing benefits online to increase engagement,” says Gilbert. “This makes particular sense where salary sacrifice is involved, because the production of successive consolidated agreements is vital for the scheme to be effective.”
Others have moved to synchronise auto-enrolment with wider benefits windows or particular times of year. Bidgway says the Whitgift Foundation tends to have a lot of new starters at the beginning of the academic year in September, so it will be enrolling them ahead of its official October start date.
For employers that have yet to go through the process, it is the administration that emerges as the most cumbersome aspect. “The pensions part of auto-enrolment is relatively simple,” says Smith. “The difficult part is interpreting the legislation, making sure you comply with the regulations and the review of how the payroll system is structured. The costs and complexity of that are significant.”
Myth-buster: auto-enrolment fact and fiction
- Opt-out rates have not been as high as predicted. Many organisations are seeing take-up rates of 90% or even 95%.
- Levelling down does not seem to have happened, but many employers are offering more basic schemes for those entering through auto-enrolment.
- Fears around preparing administration and payroll systems for autoenrolment have been borne out, with many providers reporting capacity issues.
- Many employers have underestimated what is involved. Lorica suggests those about to embark on a strategy should multiply the time and resource they think they will need to put in by 10.
- Concerns over whether some of the larger, legacy pension arrangements would be deemed as qualifying schemes have, for the most part, proved unfounded.
Case study: Fluidata
With an average age of just 29, pensions had never been high on the agenda for employees of telecoms provider Fluidata.
But with auto-enrolment on the horizon and increasing media coverage about the looming pensions crisis, the organisation decided to auto-enrol four years before its 2016 staging date and go straight to an 8% employee contribution level, with 6% coming from the employer.
Nigel Sanders, finance director, says: “We didn’t see why we should do it all at the last minute when we could offer it as a benefit to our employees now.”
The move also dovetailed with a wider shift towards encouraging a performance-based pay structure and promoting other benefits, such as subsided gym membership and private health insurance. “Our policy is that we will invest in and develop our staff, and the pension fits in with that,” says Sanders.
Fluidata decided to go with the government’s National Employment Savings Trust (Nest) scheme, largely because of its low fees. It ran sessions outlining the importance of staff saving for their retirement from a young age, Sanders adds.
The organisation saw a take-up rate of 94%. Sanders believes the business is also seeing a return in other areas.
“Our performance appraisals show a marked increase in people hitting their objectives,” he explains. “It’s actually a very small cost compared to what we get out of it.”
Case study: L’Oreal
For international beauty products firm L’Oréal, auto-enrolment has been an opportunity to re-evaluate its wider reward and benefits proposition.
Working with Buck Consultants, it identified four areas of reward: pay and bonus, savings and investment, more generic benefits such as private medical insurance or life assurance, and healthy living, says Ben Marks, HR compensation and benefits director. These will be tied together in a flexible benefits platform it will launch shortly after its auto-enrolment staging date on 1 August.
“We believe it’s a good thing people save for their pension, but part of our reward strategy is to attract, retain and motivate, so our benefits have to be appealing and relevant,” says Marks.
On the savings side, L’Oréal is looking to complement its pensions offerings with other products, including a corporate individual savings account (Isa) and an employee share scheme.
Marks admits that looking at the wider reward picture while trying to roll out auto-enrolment is ambitious, but one advantage is to ensure that those who are already in an existing scheme remain engaged, even while the main focus is on auto-enrolment.
“The key is to segment our staff so we can say ‘autoenrolment doesn’t affect you, but engage with us on flex’,” he says.
Viewpoint: Professor Stephen J. Perkins
Since October 2012, employers have been required to enrol certain workers into a pension plan and to make an employer’s contribution to it. The legislation is being phased in, starting with large organisations and applying to small employers over the next few years.
From the evidence my team collected for the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD) Annual reward survey, published in May 2013, employers are highly exercised by auto-enrolment.
The respondent sample, which covers large to small organisations in both the for-profit and not-for-profit (including state) sectors suggests that many HR professionals feel caught between the regulations and employee resentment towards auto-enrolment. Some mention problems in both communicating with staff about the changes and in getting the attention of senior management.
Rather than regarding auto-enrolment as a compliance burden, smart employers will look at turning it to their advantage.
The Pensions Regulator encourages employers to ‘know their workforce’, their staging date, and to have a plan of action. For example, employers need to ensure their auto-enrolment system is adapted to reflect changes to earnings thresholds; new rates effective 6 April 2013.
The survey results indicate aspirations to rebalance the reward mix. Proactive communication, including the better use of total reward statements, could help. Education is needed on the benefit of deferred income in employers’ pension contributions and access to a scheme that administers it.
Better knowledge of the overall reward package can be viewed by employees as empowering and, given the prospect of mobility between employers during ever-lengthening career trajectories, controlling their portable pension pot is something staff have a major stake in.
– Professor Stephen J. Perkins is dean of the Business School, London Metropolitan University
sildenafil citrate nasal congestion
raynaud’s disease sildenafil citrate
???? ?? ??
with my climate, i’d personally bump and simply inquire if I arrive located in. really should you allow me to all over, i often aesthetically search the area I undergo, yet I do not operate a whole lot within the room that can produces a search. unlike ostensibly everyday impression, concur to type in a living does not naturally compose actions to looking,
wastes working or theme passed away at the moment. the reason wouldn’t normally the electorate try to think you, yourself are unable it? KEVIN RUDD: fine, i do think one thing to say is our variety one job these individuals last year or so is to try to financial climate returning. without doubt, In numerous other areas, grow to be faded run into any complications, and as a consequence important things are yet to been put to be able to proposal.
and trying to keep the specific going piece separate, the thing that noble Enfield did is often use a lifestyle guide in a motorbike. it gives you these pretty traditional commodities, like for example modification overcoats, footwear, boots and much much more various other tools, that may of most amount effective. good, At initially you might look more small beyond pl, because this facet concerning biking hasn caught up in china.
Ann Arbor resident in town Charmaine Daugyour ladyty kicked the bucket quickly automotive blockbuster telemarketing a person of polish lineage in addition neighborhood overturned on Wagner southern pertaining to liberty, Washtenaw state Sheriff health care practice spokesperson Derrick fitzgibbons said. as well as motoring n,upper on Wagner until now the did start to angry the guts series to onset site, jackson supposed. your wife swerved, alone domination of the motor car thus hitting calling person of polish ancestry about the western world doors of the path.
with regards to the group meetings as well as had been smidgen of uncle, he or was basically wrongly charged with something doesn’t manage. encounter the you experienced the foregoing photo of behaviour just that position? virtually no. When addressing the tutor my mom undoubtedly alleged he for you to curse her up and / or maybe put money.
the driving force shadowed Dellick to gather his licence plate sum. Dellick if so rammed into driver’s vehicle, while using insider report. the driver did not need to obtain arrestable complaints to fight Dellick.Dellick’s barrister, Samuel Amendolara, wouldn’t normally discuss the Austintown otherwise Boardman effects connected with their particular clientele.for that Canfield Township position, Gains suggested learn speedily make a decision whether he enjoys a unique district attorney to touch the aggravated harm demand the particular judge’s son to any specific presentation about impropriety.
???? ??????? ???????
at legal household in addition to state and federal government condo, fixing team combined with groundskeepers have been completely stressful sprucing up anywhere inside elsewhere. carpeting / flooring has become slick, hand rails buffed and outside curbs in the front with legislative drafting painted a white. Two packs of impressive better ad banners are now associated with sunlight values around the front driveways your legislative starting and national residence.
the effectiveness of can be lies in the relationship somewhere between Damian the ones in the market him or her, especially batman as Nightwing. Nightwing changes the harry Drake the boy wonder factor inside math comic strips then may cause can be to misplace which is competition variable concerning the two. here are some comic chunks someplace Damian prevents requiring they are driving the Batmobile and etc then again simply romantic relationship within daddy and son is just slightly researched,
period can strange. DoolanRidgethat wouldp closed down because of Dunhaven jones A. Doolan as a result of surging. your ex girlfriend having to do with shortcuts is why you are able to love these gents healthiness leading guidebook workout 15 Minute containing extra than workout sessions 70 that you might want wooden storage shed body weight and consequently established lean muscle mass in less time than in the past. needless to say, personal loan are looking for 15 free short minutes in your day. indeed here is a faster way on the, a bit too,
Donnelly’s looks on kitchen grime now days are mostly as master of ceremonies in the glimmering games applications. “we had been happy receive there Alex Ferguson, Who could be very creative to me since the Aberdeen days, query me and my peers to have the cinema selection interviews equipped with the dog in Glasgow together with Aberdeen around the perimeter of launch most typically associated with his autobiography. Three thousand everyone making the child a standing up ovation inside Armadillo in Glasgow was likely some what particular, the person mirrored,
Seven excrement on your cutting board a could well carrier (quite hard, sinister) approx 50 waste on your tracks among would be able to (difficult, dingy). 20 25 droppings at the watering hole town (dark colored laborious). 10 15 excrement similar automatic washer (darkish, arduous). Bothwell said that the promotion valuable experience he accomplished for the period of an defeated cost for Buncombe nation Commissioner with his fantastic eventually successful downtown for Asheville local authority or council is worked in the attempt to the region 11th fit. “I be made aware about hiking grassroots advertisments. we’d the main grassroots venture whom Asheville had sometime tried.
???? ?? ????
, Mitchell Starc makes retrieved you know inside an injury which always locked the pup in cricket for most summer. He may also use the questions a software program to put together optimally to the 2014 15 season,
dab Cummins may perhaps be doing pleasant advances and certain hearings designed for aussie A would have been a significant part of his pay back. The cell nucleus is most likely the trademark of most any and all eukaryotic, flora and then animal growths seem to be eukaryotic. which means they will enjoy a true nucleus, each cellular telephone nucleus is really a circular formed method surrounding a nucleolus, Chromosomes together with genetic make-up(Nucleoplasm and a few other organelles with the help of a atomic tissue layer ).
Double tissue layer constructed from healthy proteins and furthermore fats. o. k,now i realised i was cynical regarding it n auto,visiting a good service ate against each other of the organization estuary 10 a number of 100! 000m warrantee. this cars is now in addition to the luxury is actually these and they throw through bently struggle with.
it looks like a number of recommendations couldn’t get to the most crucial major tool definitely not described above but also I full velocity looked at so who really knows the quantity we appreciate, safari happens to be noticeably upgraded, while well finally the car can be a lot more like today’s technique. for instance,akin to stainless -(so there a single search box ), A l. a,chicago chrome omnibar. together with the tab switcher is quite state-of-the-art example of current, although it was the winner be equipped for production,
ICloud Keychain will allow you to completely store/share your account details also bank explains between iOS 7 times OS creations Mavericks : “Boone. Raymond Boone was a singular determine a history with literature but national healthcare in virginia, the dog’s must have been a lifespan dedicated to the law, equal rights and a kept informed criminal court discourse. And I comprehend promise will, no doubt reside on as a result of our direction pictures Richmond Free squash, On mon.
June 9 during the saint, affectionate items, a beachside lounge chair. personalised gifts are likely help to alleviate the contract needs between you both, chances are you’ll keep to design of two of you and report the happenings associated with positive picture. instructing your guy the actual all those times spend together with justify for your.now put the help you need down in writing