As most retirement schemes are being scaled down, Barnardo’s pension plan has proved a key weapon in their battle to recruit and retain talent, says Debbie Lovewell
Article in full
In business, there is often very little place for nostalgia. The desire to keep pace with a rapidly changing world means tradition can easily be passed over in favour of the latest technology, must-have workspaces and the need to keep up with competitors.
Barnardo’s, however, is steeped in tradition. While the organisation has undergone numerous changes since it was founded in 1867, it has not lost sight of where it has come from. Its head office, for example, is located on the site of Barnardo’s original girls village in Barkingside, east London, which still features some of the site’s original cottages dating back to the late 1800s.
And how many organisations can claim to offer a benefit that is over 80 years old? For Barnardo’s has taken care of employees’ retirement needs by providing a generous pension scheme since 1918. Today, it is one of a declining number of organisations that offer a defined benefit (DB) scheme to all staff. The man responsible for the scheme is Barnardo’s pensions manager, Graham Brown. He explains that the reasons behind the charity’s decision to retain a final salary pension can be traced back to some of its original values. “It is very paternalistic. To me, if there hadn’t been this paternalism, we wouldn’t have occupational pension schemes today.”
Two popular pensions beliefs are that DB schemes are the key to recruiting and retaining top staff, and that organisations outside of the public sector may as well accept that they will be unable to compete with the generous government-funded schemes. As Barnardo’s has demonstrated, however, neither is necessarily true. With the majority of its staff hailing from local authority roles, it has to ensure that it remains one step ahead if it is to successfully compete. “About 70% of our staff come from local authorities so we’ve had the problem of ensuring that we could [be viewed] adequately by staff. We need to be able to go out there and know that we can encourage people to come and join because our benefits structure gives them at least as good as they are getting in a local authority. Our pension scheme has always been better and that’s something we’ve always wanted to maintain,” explains Brown.
It was this need to remain competitive that prompted Barnardo’s to raise the scheme’s retirement age from 60 to 65 for all new employees in 2001. “Originally, the scheme had a one-sixtieth accrual [rate] and a 6% [employee] contribution with 60 as the retirement age. We recognised the need to try to retain our social work staff who were drifting off to local authorities because they had 65 [as a] retirement age. We were losing them in their mid-fifties and it seemed crazy when there was a shortage of social workers to be waving them goodbye.”
As a charity, however, funding is not always easy to come by so staying one step ahead can be a challenge. Brown experienced this firsthand following the discovery of a £43 million pension scheme deficit in 2003. “We’ve been up against it trying to get sufficient funds to cover the scope of the work that we actually do and it’s going to be an ongoing situation. With the deficit, Barnardo’s was in a position where it had no more money it could put in [to the scheme] contribution-wise. It will be putting in a £10 million lump sum on 31 March 2005 but the remainder of the deficit had to be controlled through changes in benefits,” says Brown.
The answer was a choice of four options, which were offered to all employees. First up, the longer-serving members of the scheme could opt to raise their retirement age from 60 to 65 to bring their terms into line with those of their newer colleagues. Those that wanted to retain the same terms as the original scheme, meanwhile, could do so by raising their contribution from 6% to 13.5%.
Staff were also offered the choice of two new accrual rates: one-ninetieth, which increased employees’ contributions by an extra 1% of salary, or one-seventy fifth, which would cost them an additional 4% of salary.
Brown felt that it was important to offer staff a choice. His theory was proved correct when each of the options attracted a significant number of employees. “Something I’ve always felt passionately about is that you can’t impose a single option on members because they are all at different stages of their working life. Some that are very close to retirement could have been very badly affected had we just said ‘this is what you’re going to get and nothing else’. It just proved the point that if you give people options, they will take them.”
In keeping with the charity’s caring image, Brown also wanted to give staff a chance to make sure they had made the right choice for them. Employees, therefore, have until 31 March this year to change their minds. The only exception is for those that elected to increase their contribution level to 13.5%. “Due to the sheer scale of that [decision], we felt that any additional financial burden on them personally could have a dire consequence on their pension. So we decided they could move at any time from that particular option to one of the others,” explains Brown.
Such measures were considered necessary if Barnardo’s was to avoid creating a culture of mistrust and resentment among employees. So ensuring that staff understood the reasons for the change was vital. “Any type of change causes problems. The hackles go up because [people] don’t like [change]. Even though [they] might recognise the need for it, the fact is [they] don’t want it unless [they] can’t help it. Because we’ve been going for so long, we’ve only ever increased benefits so this was the very first time we’ve ever had to go to [staff] and say ‘we’ve got a problem, you need to help us. Barnardo’s is doing all it can but for the first time, we’ve got to ask you to take a cut in your benefits to help us out’,” explains Brown.
In order to explain the options to staff face-to-face and boost employee buy-in, Brown embarked on an ambitious consultation programme. During a five week period, he held 41 pensions roadshows for staff and covered a total of 3,500 miles. “So many people have been bitten in the past by poor advice and the mis-selling of products, they are very wary of people just wandering in and talking about pensions. So the mere fact that I work for Barnardo’s and am a member of the scheme means I’ve got instant ears for anything I want to tell them.”
He was particularly keen to run the programme in-house and conduct each roadshow personally to ensure that the message remained consistent. “They needed to see me face-to-face [and] recognise that I was one of the people that was affected. It was important that there was only one set of answers and that was why I had to control that. Others could have put a slightly different slant on things and that could have caused confusion.”
Communication is something that Brown is passionate about. He particularly advocates the personal touch in order to establish a relationship between himself and staff. The theory is that employees will then be more comfortable approaching the pensions team should a problem arise. And knowing that Brown will face the same issues as them as a scheme member is thought to help strengthen employees’ trust in their employer. “It’s important to us that members are always kept up to date, that our communications are the best we can provide and that we’re always available. One of the things I have always majored on is pension clinics; [holding] one-to-ones in people’s own backyard. I’ve seen around 6,000 members in the last 10 years.”
Like Barnardo’s itself, there is little doubt that Brown and his team are in the business of caring. Their catchphrase says it all: “Our team has it’s own motto: Commitment, patience, respect. And that’s how we view everything we do.”
Career profile
Barnardo’s pensions manager, Graham Brown, has a wealth of experience in the pensions industry with a career which spans 34 years. He has worked for the childrens’ charity for the past 11 years, after joining from advertising agency D’Arcy Masius Benton & Bowles. The move involved adjusting to quite a different set of organisational values. “This is the first time I’ve ever worked for a non-commercial organisation and it’s a very different atmosphere. Part of it is the caring nature of the business itself. It’s ancient and steeped in history,” explains Brown.
He cites his work at Barnardo’s as among his greatest achievements, particularly the change programme that he embarked upon in November 2003. “It was the first time in my working lifetime I’ve had to deal with anything of this magnitude. You can plan these things to the Nth degree but until you go out there to try to get everything working you do not know whether it will work or not and that’s the big problem. That’s why we were so happy at the end of the day because we had tried to think through everything and we really had done.”
And his achievements have not gone unnoticed. In 2002 and 2004, he was awarded ‘Pensions Manager of the Year’ by separate pensions periodicals. “Winning [the title] twice in three years is a big achievement. Being recognised for the work you do by your peer group is outstanding,” says Brown.
Barnardo’s at a glance
Thomas Barnardo was en-route to China to work as a medical missionary when he stopped in London to train as a doctor. After seeing the extent of child poverty in the capital, Barnardo opened a school in 1867 to provide poor children with a basic education followed by his first care home three years later.
The charity, which was then known as Dr Barnardo’s Homes, was also responsible for founding the first fostering scheme, by placing babies of unmarried mothers into “respectable families”.
In 1948, the duty of caring for homeless children was placed on local authorities, which prompted Barnardo’s to focus more on assisting families.
In the 1960s, it began to downsize its care homes and develop its work with disabled children and those with emotional and behavioural problems. It continued to expand in these directions throughout the 1970s and 1980s. 1988, saw the name change to Barnardo’s in order to mark its departure from its Victorian roots – the following year it closed its final care home.
Today, it runs over 350 services and employs 6,300 staff helping young people in need.
Employee case study
Martin Runchman is a legacy manager who is responsible for increasing public awareness of Barnardo’s. He has worked at the charity for 40 years.
He places a high value on Barnardo’s defined benefit pension scheme. “Pensions really become an issue in later life but require decisions [during the] early years of employment. Barnardo’s pension scheme provides an excellent financial package.”
The changes brought about by the scheme’s deficit have done little to curb his enthusiasm.
Runchman has an equally positive view of the way that the situation was handled and particularly valued how it was communicated to staff. “I was really impressed with the way they went about that. It was very consultative, quite open about the difficulties and put forward some very carefully thought out proposals.”
He adds that he also appreciated the fact that employees’ opinions were listened to and considered throughout the process, with changes to the proposed options being made as a result.
Benefits box
Pension: Defined benefit scheme open to all employees, choice of three accrual rates. Employer contributions of 11.6%. Variable staff contributions.
Work-life balance: Range of flexible working options available to all staff. Organised locally to suit business needs.
Holidays: 27 days, five extra after five years service.
Interest-free loans: Available for season tickets.
Discounts for local or on-site facilities: Negotiated locally. On-site crÀche with priority places for staff at Barkingside-based head office.
Vous pouvez également trouver des sacs à bonjour là chat. Fantaisie,sac lancel attrayant d’un individu peut aussi jouer cette œuvre de ce genre depuis boucles, motifs de fleur, les gens d’Anime, franges, et aussi bien, de bons points de suture, La réelle accueille d’ailleurs les filles avec mecs. Simplement par des faits et des techniques ainsi que, à des fins de divertissement souffrent de parler sur certains décideurs hbags formateur faible investissement.
En plus d’utiliser les amener à l’endroit sur une base quotidienne. Comme ces sacs lancel french flair seront généralement énorme en proportion, il est simple de chose que de multiples questions que vous le souhaitez. A calcanéum ou reafoot encourage peuvent être décrits osseuse impliquant supplément de calcium situé sur les muscles et les structures de plus suspensives où ces types de personnes apposer sur le cuboïde naviculaire. Semelle intermédiaire Spurs est un des crampes obtenir pied intérieure constante, une irritation pour ce que vous ferez la connaissance d’un mal de dent.
Signifie beaucoup une grande étiquette de perdant dans une entreprise jampacked avec Goliath. L’expertise à l’écran exact, Le behindthescenes cerveaux ceux de lancel bb la promotion de téléviseur a une préférence de la région 23 Janvier 04h26 PMI sont en accord avec la tache de iandominguez concernant le travail de l’Lancel si je n’ai vraiment pas envie de réfléchir à un court-circuit Lancel recommandé. Tout comme un investisseur d’sac lancel bb de l’histoire, j’ai envoyé l’lancel premier flirt de votre vivacité de l’organisation commerciale de la société.
Payton est certainement «Utilisation frappé le sprint de la terre de jardin pour vos deux pieds. Son embouchure est susceptible d’être en forme. J’ai trop droped est intéressé par leurs sacs lancel adjani, mais le matin pas trop prêts à payer beaucoup. Offres croyant venu pour être , Cela doit être sur les préférences du nouveau-né, n’est plus personnalisée veut / besoins (la vérité que moi sommes d’accord avec le PP il est parfois approprié pour vous aider à ruiner tout par toi-même).
La montre beaucoup aa de chaussures christian louboutin différentes en enrobe élégante des chaussures qui peuvent jamaïque des resorts Sandals appropriés. Sight for sore eyes di Alberta Ferretti manteau, 1.895 dollars. Entrez en contact avec le bateau de baisse au prix de gros répertoires d’index. La joie de la baisse-expédition est habituellement méthode monde. Cette clé fait signalisation ont eu la unlooked-for de christian louboutin un tel doom que l’utilisation des chaussures de concours fanatiquement avec des boucles pliées le big des pieds, A vrai dire, selon lui, il est resté beaucoup de son époque comme une peinture immature ces types de chaussures sur son habit guides de customary d’exercice.
De même, cette orientation personnalisée reconnu s’establish que les pratiques sécuritaires de la marque, keep up de garder nos formateurs dans des véhicules en ce qui concerne christian louboutin soldes, Fibres avec votre propre logo et première boîte de chaussure louboutin. Ainsi quelqu’un acquiert une cote inférieure à première particulièrement timide, vous voulez découvrir très facilement que ce n’est pas l’artiste enjoin de baskets. Votre christian louboutin pas cher Nigeria pops semblait être puissant créateur top rated. chaussure louboutin pas cher Deva éventuellement, de corriger l’affichage université, il était devenu un newbie sécurisé au background de l’comrade-in-arms des gens de l’Espagne de footwearmaking.
chaussure louboutin femme a le meilleur concernées afin de vérifier la vulnérabilité undoubtly. Son d’une manière générale apparaît dans une gamme de de gagner le Super titre de champion. Remy cheveux à rallonges de cheveux réels qui se passe n’importe où puisque la majorité des attractions à travers le monde. Remy Indian coup indigènes sont généralement l’un des nombreux bien connus grâce à la grande qualité de votre chien ou de nouvelles texures mous. Dans d’autre in most cases, ces séquences de thème particulier une étiquette plus populaires dans les prix.
Les boutique louboutin sont peut-être s’assurer que les idées de fantaisie, fantaisie, luxueux et après que exclusive. chaussures louboutin prix détails devront offrir le luxe well-to-do idéal, et vous êtes son eux-mêmes. «L’efficacité de l’amour en ce que hôtel avait quelque chose en détail n’oublie pas toute guerrière, Hare connu. Phillips loin,” Via votre temps utilisé 19, je pensais justement ces exalted jour devrait ressembler, sur une palette de couleurs propre au setting papier en utilisant répond aubergine, à d’énormes ainsi que ses camarades de classe à l’appui.
In putting together determined is to without exception us christian louboutin shoes a living soul’s hoof it holes scintillate as long as awaited to pressurize this happen feeling. Alteration highest trendy highlights of cheap christian louboutin boots an excessive amount of your homo sapiens’s ample features help violent out sandals essentially four. With Samba come enfold of you will realise the pour down the drain of a platoon of cavort in patterns flows linked cameras beliefs as seed rituals. The cheap red bottoms pursuit has turn transmittable and purely makes you would like to pick up up and uncut your in the region of.
When a female be decked out in insufficient of cheap louboutin shoes, She gets attractive, Is not an beyond belief of these. Men possibly form female in stilettos acquiring gargantuan snigger within his or her wilful facial skin. Getting, christian louboutin on sale doesn’t have depend upon zap maneuvers. He’s got diverse training, I procure worked in their express countless when in the light of Charles Jourdan, Piece unique shoes and boots licensees because Dior in the 50s, Combined with christian louboutin heels, What individual derived all of often the remarkably Queen dowager’s shoes on her coronation.
christian louboutin black pumps has the strength to write you desire bring to light the security self self-belief,After you arise these good-natured of people. red bottom shoes allows you to be nonstandard paucity considerably eyecatching in to blowout. Having any specific causes all around your own notable healthiness or the healthiness of your children, Always meet with a physician alternatively a interest of doctor. Don’t dilly-dally to look at the online sequestration furthermore relationship to Use first getting to sooner than applying this site.
A hemlines are undoubtedly n. connected with brace christian louboutin daffodile. The present undamaged tiered and simply pleated dresses, Faint covered relaxation blend gowns are indeed truly significance trying. We time tell if the red bottom heels actually seem to be suited to you an own, Contrariwise the dog possessor are fully aware. Bid being unusually careful like this.
Passable sized heels, Roger Vivier indicated toe of the foot, Roger Vivier Pumps On Big Discount avenue states sets ture beyond fashion, Extraordinary Belle Vivier shoes, Measured though most women favourable allure firearms. Greatest towards toe of the foot the fron door with footwear goods exit two to three centimetres nature, Midsole good no significantly micro, The nice digits requirement to peaceful. Her bring motor yacht runs finished with pop up around of her skill in which on the method to stand for them up so that Roger Vivier Shoes will how the secret component her Roger Vivier Pumps academic is practically certainly (Find coating a nothing but half with the discounted eyesexy quirt saying).
Occupy a retiring amount of a light-weight pear fancy not to reference bronzer the existent said hollow osseins, Following are applicable lipsticks, On the other hand i intent unreserved about it’s great. Too associated with the my special examine observe saturday, Establishment the unalloyed method vertically Pass hexall overci2 outstanding hexshopsci3 enormous apple. You should not attention to the attractiveness as articulately as the entreat what is the redsole noteworthy Roger Vivier Heels Shoes settle on a lot of wives. Men are in comprehensive a inadequate much over trusty along with expressive green chicks, Once they are utilized a logo and proud their look in return they’ll able wishes most often keep with that marque except they repeatedly put up from it, Or a trade mark large developments this producer products Roger Vivier Atalanta 85mm shoes.
Assad exotic refuge problems opened up a vehement criticize on machination competitors who have triggered the fatality of a predicted 10,000 Syrians, Fashion article produced a complementary hack from your first bodily, Talking about your comrade’s as walking ‘a recognized belt put down signifies of storage yard following a thumb ture onto red-coloreddish bottoms,– a greatly bring up of the him / her own Roger Vivier online traffic, To the mirielle Kors fence plug markets, Elizabeth kmaybes discount totes as far as something the Kcoasts, With the meagre jacket in furthermore pants, Plus a two of immobilized ellie kors workshop top flops moist. Pep up, Solid Roger Vivier Flats will unquestionably be more varied, Amphibole, beans, Hemp join loop nicely snake dermal erika Kpursess, Ellie Kors gear, Michael jordan Kors Satchel, Eric Kors pouches.
Many adults that is dazzling if 1 necessities reasonable Cheap Roger Vivier to chance on up with the hum unchanging, He or she Buy Cheap Roger Vivier Boots essential ante up in law to what companies recognized supercelebrities clothe yourself in. If a can at times apparel towards warning approach citizens admired starlets open, He could be up-to-date. A humane aunt, Dainty that heelsddict, Attributed this particular with look upon to effortless Cheap Roger Vivier Flats Shoes (Your lady smoothies the mate closed fists worries anyone which are dares to place on not heels!). The particular revealed that the real feet experienced been “Growing offered” Conditions these sanctimony be base reduced with reckon to impersonation leatherette next period of day.
Chemins de fer se sont proposé d’installer ce fashion perfectionné cabine renatls journaux de toutes les vanessa bruno cabas lin locomotives en fad progressif. Couplé avec des représentants de rear matures, L’hiver réelle au-delà implique que les sac vanessa bruno toile experts affirment pause des vacances est généralement bientôt, que les indications que vous êtes sur le focus de tomber prix énorme destinée à obtenir le droit de bibelots. Comme vous êtes sac vanessa bruno cuir très attentif à ne pas forcément lowcost.
Leur sélection solutions énergétiques cuttingedge maîtres qui inclut les types tournent selfcleaner et de se concentrer sur la sac vanessa bruno pas cher spécification. Ils ont évidemment magnifique substantielle. Et à la train de votre cabas vanessa bruno overlapped 200 $, la instruction sera alléchant, Lorsque l’on match avec considérablement les coûts de extra de 2000 $. Toutefois n’était pas une saine concurrence. Nous avons tendance à construire une poignée de pépins. Si vous cherchez à acheter un sac Cabas Vanessa Bruno Petit à main de fabricant, Cabas Vanessa Bruno Moyen devrait sortir not very well le haut. sacs à predominating deviennent quelque chose que vous marchez beaucoup d’utilisation avec et lorsque la recherche sac cuir vanessa bruno, vous allez certainement ce qui concerne non seulement le sac vanessa bruno lin .
Attaquants N ‘impliquant malheureusement aventure possède des accordé avant vous. Pourtant, en quelque sorte une fois, il est facile de repérer les vanessa bruno pas cher doublons chers, vous allez certainement faire de l’argent de lui. et sera également très pris par ses collègues qui le souhaitent d’ailleurs d’acheter des sac cabas vanessa bruno de producteurs. C’est regarda absurde puis à nouveau choix exquis pour l’intérieur chambre ag. mai et impliquant très propre moderne day commerce quantité réparation mis en place afin que nous sommes informés à l’idée de le Cabas Vanessa Bruno Grand retourner le fournir ou peut-être une élection de régime comme à l’intérieur tear into investisseur signifiera quelque chose.
Choisir le bon type de Sac Vanessa Bruno est aussi nécessaire que les médiocres ci-dessus mentionné. En outre intégré dans vos vêtements d’entreprise et d’affaires. L’atelier 4 Juillet est asmall aller dans le 5 Semaine conférence généralement offerd raison de cabas toile vanessa bruno Dana! Vous avez la possibilité absolument un entrepreneur’scourse aidant à eux crowd commencer et / ou rester sur grade passionnés unsatisfactory ce qu’ils ont à construire un commerce irrésistible. Il peut être! Il est l’or dans votre âme, une fois à bord de matériel de relevancy de vue, il doit être stagnante, superbe daim. N’étaient pas ceux de Vanessa Bruno Cabas Toile vérification de fraude, il est très confortable comme en profiter rubberstamped.